Please Stop Saying “Content is King”

content is kingWe’ve all heard that increasingly common search marketing mantra, “content is king.”  It certainly sounds nice, and if it was true, it could really be a wonderful thing, because it suggests that all you need to have a well-performing, highly ranking and highly converting site is to treat people the way they want to be treated and give them an awesome site to experience.

Now, I am not Matt Cutts and I am not omniscient, but I do know this: Content is not king.  And here’s how I know this: I can point to innumerable instances of poorly written, ugly, blatantly spammy pages ranking well for keyphrases that they did not “deserve” to rank for.  And these nasty, thin, worthless pages far outnumber (even post-Panda) instances where beautiful, engaging pages that just focus on “building a community” and “great content,” but do not have strong ranking signals, rank well.

googlebotAnd, lamentable as it is, this makes perfect sense, because Googlebot is a bot, and bots do not possess the complex, higher-order intelligence that allows humans to assess the “usefulness” of a site.  In a simpler, more perfect world,* a search engine crawler might be able to do so.  It could go, “You know, this page’s offerings are more engaging, and the site itself has that, how do you say, je ne sais quoi.  I’ll rank it above this ugly exact-match domain site with a ton of links pointing to it, because THAT site looks BORING.”  Alas, our world is not so simple, nor so perfect, so Googlebot must use ranking signals as an indirect indicator of a page’s usefulness.  These signals, generally speaking, correlate rather well to a site’s quality.  The number of links a page has pointing to it, for example, should give a search engine crawler a good idea of how popular that page is.  However, these signals do not correlate perfectly, and—as we all intimately know—they can be gamed.  This state of affairs is not ideal, but it’s worthless to take the stance that if you just pretend that it is not where we are currently at, then your problems will go away.

I regularly hear that search marketers should only employ tactics that mirror our vision of a more perfect Googlebot by focusing solely on what we think search engines should emphasize.  This stance is as curious as it is ubiquitous.  Last I checked, clients pay marketers for results, not for potential results, provided our vision of a better tomorrow becomes a reality.  In this particular case, shunning what works might be the result of a rosier outlook on the world, but it’s still fatal from a results perspective.

It comes down to this: Everyone—Google, search marketers, site administrators, and (most of all) users—desperately wants content to be king, but it’s not, at least not yet.  It’s in a power-sharing agreement, and it will be for as long as Google’s algorithm dictates rankings.

*Perhaps.  I, personally, would rather have a bot—even one that can be gamed—rank options for me over being force-fed choices based on opinions of quality, opinions which are inherently subjective.  But that’s just me.

Posted in B2B, B2C, Blog, Content Development Strategy, eCommerce, Search Engine Optimization (SEO), Web Analytics Optimization | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Four great resources for getting started on Google+

Google+ has over 90 million users as of January 2012 according to Google+ News. Now that Google has started “Search plus Your World”, Google+ is a significant contributor to your organic search rankings. Also, the new Google search interface has separated personal from non-personal results.

personalized search results on Google

Several bloggers have commented on the importance of Google+ in your online marketing mix. You will need to consider Google+ as part of your social strategy and your search strategy.

Here are some great resources for those getting started with Google+

  1. For Developers
    Use Google’s badge generator to give you the code snippet you need to add the Google+ badge to your site.
  2. Google+ Badge Dev FAQ
    Get answers to your developer questions on this page.
  3. For social marketers
    This is a great post by Mark Traphagen on how to get your Google+ brand page to work.
  4. For search marketers
    This post from Thomas Ballantyne provides some great insights into how powerful Google+ is when it comes to search results, specifically image search. All the previously known factors to influence search results for images are totally blown away.
Posted in Search Engine Optimization (SEO), Social Media Marketing | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

SEO Can’t Go It Alone

success graphThroughout my career in Search Engine Optimization (SEO), it has come to my attention that many believe SEO success begins and ends with “good SEO.”  Although vague, this may have been the case in the early days of SEO.  But due to Google’s algorithm evolving and advancing so quickly over past years, a successful SEO campaign not only requires white hat SEO techniques, but is also dependent upon the engagement of many other marketing teams and experts, such as the following:

  • Analysts
  • Developers
  • Creative
  • PR/Social Media

Let’s take a closer look at the roles that each of these individuals play in the execution of a successful SEO campaign, as well as the responsibilities of an SEO Expert.

Analysts

In many cases, the SEO Expert fulfills the role of the SEO Analyst, as well.  Whether your team blends the two roles into one, or has the resources to dedicate individuals to each role, the Analyst is crucial to the success of SEO.  Prior to the implementation of SEO recommendations and best practices, the Analyst’s first responsibility is to ensure that tracking capabilities have been set up properly.  Has the Google Analytics snippet of code been inserted into the client’s website template page?  Does the Tracking Status verify that data is being received?  Are filters in place to exclude internal traffic from the web analytics data?  And so forth.  The Analyst will then want to record the client’s current organic rankings and web analytics (organic visits, organic bounce rate, organic conversion rate, etc.) as a benchmark.  This data will be used as a comparison in the future in order to measure the performance of the SEO efforts.  The Analyst will also work with the SEO Expert to set up conversion goals and funnels.  From there, the Analyst is responsible for regularly reporting the web analytics data from organic sources so the SEO Expert can monitor the results of the SEO campaign.

Developers

Although an SEO Expert is expected to be somewhat savvy in terms of technology, various web programming languages (e.g. HTML, JavaScript, CSS, etc.), and Content Management Systems (CMS), he/she will work with the Developer to properly execute related SEO initiatives.  While it is the SEO Expert’s responsibility to identify potential SEO “hazards” such as crawlability issues due to the usage of Flash files or iFrames, duplicate content, broken links, or un-friendly SEO URL’s, the collaboration of the SEO Expert and Developer is critical in the resolution of such issues.  For example, once notified by the SEO Expert, the Developer is then responsible for accessing the CMS and implementing canonical tags to resolve duplicate content issues, 301 redirects for broken links, and URL structures that follow the SEO best practices recommended by the SEO Expert.  In addition, the Developer can also create HTML pages for existing Flash or iFrame pages in order to improve crawlability and loading time, both critical SEO factors.

Creative

The Creative group includes Editors, Copywriters, Designers, and the Content team.  At the core of SEO is quality research and selection of targeted keywords.  Once the SEO Expert has chosen keywords to target, he/she then works closely with the Editor and Copywriters to ensure proper placement, frequency, and density of these keywords within the body copy, headings, and sub-headings of each optimized web page.

On the forefront, it may not seem as though the Designer has much of an impact on SEO results; however, the design, navigation, and usability all have an effect on the quality of a site; and therefore, its optimization for search engines.  In addition, Designers can work with the SEO Expert to effectively organize content, include navigational breadcrumbs, and design a clear and engaging call-to-action (CTA).

In some cases, the Content team may consist of the Editors, Copywriters, and Designers; in others, it may be a separate department.  In either case, the ultimate goal is to develop new and relevant content with which the client’s target audience can engage.  For example, the SEO Expert may discover a new keyword opportunity that can be capitalized on by building a new content web page.  The targeted keyword provides the foundation for the topic of the web page, and guides the Content team as they write copy, capture images and graphics, create videos, and the like.  The SEO Expert can then optimize each piece of content and syndicate it to other relevant and reputable sites in order to increase content sharing initiatives, as well as gain backlinks to the client’s domain.

PR/Social Media

The PR and Social Media teams also work closely with the SEO Expert.  For effective optimization, press releases should be reviewed by the SEO Expert prior to syndication to ensure proper placement of keywords, as well as proper usage of anchor text.  Furthermore, the Social Media team should collaborate with the SEO Expert to optimize social profiles with customized URL’s; to incorporate targeted keywords in the Info and About sections, and image title and descriptions; and to share optimized content (credited to the Content team) in regular posts.

And last, but not least…

SEO Expert

In summary, an SEO Expert not only needs to be able to collaborate with the above mentioned teams in order to generate and analyze web analytics reports, identify crawlability issues, ensure proper placement of keywords, recognize the difference between high-quality and low-quality design, discover new opportunities for content creation, optimize press releases and social media profiles (whew!), but he/she also needs to manage and execute the core SEO functions.  Keyword research is, without a doubt, an integral component of any SEO campaign.  Targeting an ineffective keyword not only throws off the initiatives of every team member involved in the SEO campaign, but it is also likely to lead to increased organic bounce rates and lower conversion rates.  On-page recommendations; such as title tags, meta descriptions, H1tags, image alt tags, internal linking and anchor text recommendations; are all vital to the improved rankings of a specific web page, as well as the traffic being driven to that page.  And utilizing all avenues of link building (e.g. authority links, link exchange, paid links (to be used sparingly), directory links, social bookmarking, content syndication, PR/article syndication, guest blogging/forums, etc.) to gain backlinks to the client’s site.

This post is not meant to be an all inclusive description of the roles and responsibilities of an SEO Expert or those team members that work together with the SEO Expert to obtain search optimization goals.  Rather, it is meant to demonstrate how crucial Analysts, Developers, Creative, PR and Social Media resources are to the success of an SEO campaign.

Posted in B2B, B2C, Blog, Content Development Strategy, Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO), eCommerce, Search Engine Optimization (SEO), Social Media Marketing | Tagged | Leave a comment

Great Examples in Viral Video Marketing: VW

Last year’s most-talked about Super Bowl ad was undeniably VW’s ad with a little boy dressed as Darth Vader. For the few of you out there who haven’t seen it, said little boy walks around dressed like Vader, “The Imperial March” playing in the background, trying to use The Force to start random household objects. He finally “succeeds” by starting his dad’s 2012 VW Passat.

It’s a super cute commercial, and apparently hit home with A LOT of people, considering it’s had almost 50 million You Tube views.

On January18 VW released a 60 second teaser for this year’s Super Bowl ad. Again, it features “The Imperial March.” But with DOGS.

Again, it looks like VW has another viral hit on its hands–after only a week it’s had well over 7 million views, and has been shared on Facebook by the likes of Cesar Millan, Mashable and probably 90% of my Facebook friends.

So what makes VW’s Super Bowl ads such great examples in viral online marketing? Lots of things, the primary of which are:

  • They’re fun
  • VW obviously knows who its target audience is–car buyers in their 30s and 40s who like style and safety and who have a fondness for Star Wars (which was a staple for a lot of us born in the ’70s and ’80s)
  • They’re creative and stylish
  • They release just enough to get you invested and wanting more
  • They make you laugh (anyone who doesn’t at least smirk at Chewbacca dog has no soul)
  • Timing

That last one is super important. Timing. The Super Bowl is on February 5, meaning VW chose to release this year’s teaser just over two weeks before The Big Game. That’s two weeks for people to view the video, share the video, talk about the video and get excited to see the entire commercial. Last year’s commercial had leaked footage that had the web buzzing for days leading up to the Super Bowl, and that commercial had EVERYONE talking afterwards.

Sure, VW has the brand and the money to run an awesome advertising campaign–and they do. But they’re also showing (or, at least, Deutsch is convincing VW’s marketing department) that they know how to create buzz and make something go viral. Volkswagen and Old Spice are quickly becoming two of my favorite brands from a viral marketing perspective (I drive a Ford and as a female don’t use Old Spice products, so I have no skin in this game), as they are two companies who aren’t afraid to take a risk, be funny, and go viral.

What do you think some of the best recent viral marketing campaigns have been? Discuss below!

Posted in B2B, B2C, Blog, Content Development Strategy, eCommerce, Lead Generation, Search Engine Optimization (SEO), Social Media Marketing, Videos | Tagged , | Leave a comment